Caitlin Coleman, Joshua Boyle and their 2 children held hostage by the Taliban who want “money, power, friends” in exchange for their release
(Still via Sabiq Jihadmal)
Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (Taliban) have released a video via Sabiq Jihadmal that shows hostages Caitlin Coleman (31) from Pennsylvania and husband Joshua Boyle (33) of Toronto, Canada delivering an urgent message allegedly on 3rd December 2016 to the governments of US and Canada. The couple’s two young children also appear for the first time in public view, both boys were born in captivity. The eldest is seen giggling as he appears to be distracted by something off camera.
Coleman and Boyle were kidnapped in 2012 whilst traveling through the Wardak province of Afghanistan, Coleman was 7 months pregnant at the time. As Phillymag stated, they “decided to hike across the steppes of Central Asia. They dreamed of eating exotic foods, meeting the locals and doing aid work” but their journey was stopped short allegedly at the hands of the Haqqani network that previously held US soldier Bowe Bergdahl captive for 5 years. The couple have appeared in an earlier video, see following link for details and background on the hostages,
The Taliban are prepared to release the couple in exchange for “money, power, friends”. Coleman states, “we are told there are Afghans who are prisoners in Kabul that these men care about and do not want to be punished.” In May of this year Islamic Emirate criticised use of the death penalty against Mujahideen saying,
“This announcement by Ashraf Ghani clearly demonstrates his frailty due to him testing his strength against defenseless prisoners while at the same time, it holds no legal basis because these political prisoners are handed the death penalty by the most corrupt and incompetent judicial body in the world. The prisoners sentenced to death are mostly poor individuals who could not afford bribing the regime prosecutors and judges due to the economic conditions and are therefore witnessing the result of their destitution. Such actions by the Kabul administration will amount to nothing more than a war crime carried out against freedom seeking oppressed and defenseless prisoners. The execution of inmates currently imprisoned can have no positive outcome for the crumbling Kabul administration but will naturally have serious repercussions.”
This is one of a series of statements highlighting alleged regime abuses against prisoners also documented in numerous reports from international human rights organizations. Islamic Emirate also published a letter from the families of detainees to the UN and Secretary General of NATO concerning appalling treatment of detainees.
Anas Haqqani and Qari Abdul Rashid Omari (a.k.a. Hafiz Rashid). NDS photos via Khaama Press.
As Long War Journal reported in September, Taliban threatened blood would be spilled if Anas Haqqani, the brother of the group’s deputy emir who is also the operational leader of the Haqqani Network was executed.
Coleman makes it clear that if this is not addressed and demands not met, the family face retaliation, harm and punishment.
Transcript of video
In the name of Allah the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful,
“Fighting in the sacred month is for aggression committed in the sacred month and for all violations is legal contribution So whoever has assaulted you, then assault him in the same way that he assaulted you. And fear Allah and know that Allah is with us who fear Him” (Al- Baqarah:194)
Caitlin Coleman speaking
“Today is December 3rd 2016. We have waited since 2012 for somebody to understand our problems. This is a Kafkaesque nightmare in which we find ourselves. We understand both sides hate us and are content to leave us and our two surviving children in these problems but we can only ask and pray that somebody will recognize the atrocities these men carry out against us as so called retaliation in their ingratitude and hypocrisy.
My children have seen their mother defiled. We ask quickly in our collective 14th year of prison, urge the government on both sides to reach some agreement to allow us freedom.
Obama your legacy on leaving office is probably important to you and our lives and these of our children are to us so please don’t become the next Jimmy Carter so give the offender something so they and you can save face and leave the region permanently.
Donald Trump, the legacy of a millenia of femen worship in this country is that those who speak high and noble of Islamic ideals are not simply going to release our family easily because it is correct, they want money, power, friends, you must give them these things before progress can be made. A 5 year hostage taking is too long and indicates failure on every side. Believe us, we have tried to explain the irony and sin to these men but to no avail.
We need you and the government to step up and do us a favour here and solve the problems. We are told there are Afghans who are prisoners in Kabul that these men care about and do not want to be punished. Indeed they threaten to retaliate against our family, that their group will do us harm and punish us so we ask that you are merciful to their people and God Willing they will release us.”
Joshua Boyle speaking
“And to whichever state department official has to watch this video, we both know the President is not going to see it or the coming President and that the decision ultimately probably lies with you but there is no point explaining that to our captors. And I am sure you think our family could get out of this if we wanted and I can only promise you that we can’t.
You like us probably underestimate the arrogant ignorance that pervades these people and don’t understand we’re dealing with the people who think that America killed all the monkeys in their country and the drones are listening to them sleep at night. There is no point explaining to them that we are the worst bandits to have a prisoner exchange with.
They really will not settle this until they get what they are demanding so I can only ask that you will please quickly try to resolve this for our sake and the sake of our children and we can talk about compensation later. But it has been more than 4 years so I do plead with you please be quick.”
Video message on screen from Taliban posted by Sabiq Jihadmal
This is a clear message!
“The release of the couple and their children will not come into realization until all our demands are met!
We advise you against any evasiveness and any attempt of provocation because this is of no benefit to you!
For if you agree to our demands then we will release your citizens but if not then you will face dangerous consequences. Do not even dare to try us with our patience because we know very well how to respond to the oppressors and arrogates.
Know that the failure is destined for the one who does not know how to respond in a given situation.”
It remains to be seen how US will handle attempts to recover Coleman, Boyle and children. Earlier efforts to free captives have been heavily criticised and in one incident led to the deaths of 2 prisoners held by Al Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS). In January 2015 aid worker Warren Weinstein (73) and Italian prisoner Giovanni Lo Porto (37) were killed in a controversial US “signature” drone strike near the Afghanistan/Pakistan border confirmed by President Barack Obama in April who accepted “full responsibility” for their deaths.
The Washington Post reported the following on US practice from a Special Forces Officer,
“In June 2015, Lt. Col. Jason Amerine testified before Congress that the nation’s effort to recover American hostages held overseas is ‘dysfunctional’ and mired in bureaucratic red tape and failure.
‘Is the system broken?’ Amerine asked rhetorically during the hearing of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. ‘Layers upon layers of bureaucracy hid the extent of our failure from our leaders. I believe we all failed the commander in chief by not getting critical advice to him.’”
US did have some success in 2015 exchanging 5 Taliban prisoners, Abdul Haq Wasiq, Mullah Norullah Nori, Khairullah Khairkhwa, Mohammed Nabi and Mohammad Fazl for Bowe Bergdahl. See following report from NBC as Bergdahl takes his first steps to freedom.
“When the Taliban takes the girl next door”
“Al Qaeda prisoners Warren Weinstein and Giovanni LoPorto allegedly reverted to Islam before being martyred in US drone strike”
“Free…. Bowe Bergdahl exchanged for 5 Taliban, a determined father and establishing dialogue”
Islamic Emirate taking vengeance from the prisoners is a sign of cowardice and downfall”
“Islamic Emirate: Prisoners should not be made the prey of politics”
Carol Anne Grayson is an independent writer/researcher on global health/human rights and is Executive Producer of the Oscar nominated, Incident in New Baghdad . She is a Registered Mental Nurse with a Masters in Gender Culture and Development. Carol was awarded the ESRC, Michael Young Prize for Research 2009, and the COTT ‘Action = Life’ Human Rights Award’ for “upholding truth and justice”. She is also a survivor of US “collateral damage”.